Subscribe Now
Forgot Password?

Weekly News, Analysis, and Commentary

Legal & Regulatory Feature

Wikimedia Commons and Ninianpeckitt

75% of Doctors Accuse Colleagues of Unnecessary Procedures

Biloine W. Young • Fri, May 30th, 2014

Print this article

Seventy-five percent of doctors think their contemporaries order at least one unnecessary test or procedure a week, according to a survey by Choosing Wisely reported by writer Zack Budryk of Fierce HealthCare.

The reasons physicians gave for ordering extraneous tests were malpractice concerns (52%), to be extra cautious (36%), to get more information so as to reassure themselves on their diagnosis (30%) and patient insistence on the procedure (28%). About 5% said they had been motivated by the fee-for-service system.

Budryk wrote that 47% of the respondents reported that one patient a week requests an unnecessary test or procedure. When that happens, 48% of the doctors reported that they advise the patient against it but eventually defer to the patient’s wishes.

"I think we're afraid of not being liked, " Donald Ford, M.D., a vice president at Hillcrest Hospital in Mayfield Heights, Ohio, told Kaiser Health News. "We want to be the hero to the patient."

None of the doctors responding to the survey thought that Medicare was in the best position to address the problem and more than half (58%) put the responsibility for correcting the problem on the doctors themselves. More than three in four (78%) of those who responded said it would help to have more time to talk with patients and 61% said that changing the system of payment so physicians were not incentivized to order more tests would be effective.

Send to a Friend

The article link will be sent to the email address you provide

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Friend's Email (required)


One Response to “75% of Doctors Accuse Colleagues of Unnecessary Procedures”

  1. P.G. Benton, MD, JD says:

    This is the much larger problem:–03-14?utm-source=tod&utm-medium=email&utm-campaign=tips

    Today much more surgery is done than is indicated by EBM guidelines, and “pushing the envelope” is now accepted even though as outpatients ACDF patients are documented to expire from sudden bleed –> asphyxia. In hospitals they can usually be saved by quick evacuation of the hematoma, but not at home where patients often may die needlessly.

Leave a Reply


Email Address (will not be published)